active

4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

$587,000

$355 per ft²

3 Bed

2 Bath

1,652 Sq Ft

0.3 Acres

Listing Office: Mountain Life Realty, dba MLR

Image 1 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 2 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 3 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 4 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 5 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 6 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 7 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 8 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 9 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 10 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 11 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 12 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 13 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 14 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 15 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 16 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 17 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 18 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 19 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 20 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 21 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 22 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 23 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 24 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 25 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 26 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 27 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 28 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 29 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 30 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 31 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 32 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 33 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 34 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 35 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 36 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 37 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 38 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 39 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 40 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 41 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 42 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Image 43 of property listing at 4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429

Nestled in the heart of historic Macks Inn, this adorable Modified A-frame cabin offers the ultimate mountain escape. Surrounded by a lush, wooded landscape, the property perfectly balances secluded charm with modern convenience. Currently operating as a successful active short-term rental. Inside, you'll find a warm, inviting atmosphere designed for relaxation. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home features "cozy-chic" styling and rustic touches that reflect the beauty of the outdoors. After a day of adventure, retreat to the comfortable living spaces or relax on the deck to soak in the forest sights and sounds. The location is unbeatable for outdoor enthusiasts. You are just minutes away from the river for fishing, kayaking, and float trips. Plus, the west entrance to Yellowstone National Park is an easy 30-minute drive, making this a prime home base for tourists. Whether you're looking to continue its legacy as a top-rated rental or seeking your own private piece of Idaho history, this Macks Inn gem is ready for its next chapter. Don't miss your chance to own a slice of the pines!

Listing Agent:

License Number:

Offered by: Mountain Life Realty, dba MLR

Office Phone: 208-982-0309

MLS: #2185455

Snake River Regional MLS

Date Added: 04/11/2026 02:41:44 pm

Last Update: 04/16/2026 09:43:23 pm

Days on Market: 20

Interior

Appliances: Dishwasher, Double Oven, Dryer, Refrigerator, Electric Water Heater
Laundry: Main Level
Flooring: Carpet, Laminate
A/C: false, None
Heating: true, Electric, Cadet Style
Fireplace: 1, Wood Burning, Fireplace

Exterior

Parking: Carport, Dirt

Construction

Roofing: Metal
General: Frame, Wood Siding, Two, Concrete Perimeter

Location

Originating MLS: Snake River
County: Fremont

Lot

Zoning: ISLAND PARK RALPH A THOMPSON SUB LOT 30 BLK 3 SEC 36 TWP 14 RGE 43, RPI01220030300
Fencing: None

Utilities

Utilities: Fall River Power
Water: Well
Sewer: Community Sewer

Financial

Source: Snake River
Exclusions: Personal Items.

Property

Year Built: 1992
Type: Single Family Home
Parcel #: RPI01220030300

Schools

Elementary: Island Park Charter School
Middle: North Fremont A215JH
High: North Fremont A215HS

04/11/2026$587,000@ 355 per ft²Listed

04/11/2026Active

Listing Broker

Melissa Ward

1 @

Email: melissa@archibaldbagley.com

Location: AL

MLS: #2185455

Source: Snake River Regional MLS

<IMG SRC='https://d37ukvrrv3in12.cloudfront.net/mls/logos/idx.png' ALT='IDX'><IMG SRC='https://d37ukvrrv3in12.cloudfront.net/mls/logos/equalhousing.png' ALT='Equal Housing'> All information is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed. Consult with your real estate professional to verify the provided information. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data exchange (“IDX”) program of Snake River MLS®. The IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All information is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed. Consult with your real estate professional to verify the provided information. NOTICE: All real estate advertised herein is subject to the Federal Fair Housing Act, which Acts make it illegal to make or publish any advertisement that indicates any preference, limitation, or discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national origin. Snake River MLS® and this broker will not knowingly accept any advertising for real estate which is in violation of the law. All persons are hereby informed that all dwellings advertised are available on an equal opportunity basis. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright© 2026 Snake River MLS®. All Rights Reserved. Data displayed may be a portion of, and not a complete set of all listings published in the MLS.

View Listing

4214 Old Hwy 191, Island Park, ID 83429 is a 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1,652 Sq Ft, 0.3 Acres, Single Family Home built in 1992.

This property is currently available and was listed by Snake River Regional MLS on 04/11/2026 02:41:44 pm. The MLS # for the property is MLS #2185455.