Skip to content
  • Featured Listings
  • MLS Search
  • About Us
  • Agents
  • Contact
  • Featured Listings
  • MLS Search
  • About Us
  • Agents
  • Contact
Listings
Home > Listings > ID > Sugar City > 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448
active

545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448

$535,000
$173 per ft²
6 Bed
4 Bath
3,085 Sq Ft
0.13 Acres
Listing Office: Boss Real Estate
Image 1 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 2 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 3 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 4 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 5 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 6 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 7 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 8 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 9 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 10 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 11 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 12 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 13 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 14 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 15 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 16 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 17 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 18 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 19 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 20 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 21 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 22 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 23 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 24 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 25 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 26 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 27 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 28 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 29 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 30 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 31 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 32 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 33 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 34 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 35 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 36 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 37 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 38 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 39 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 40 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 41 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 42 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 43 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 44 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 45 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 46 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Image 47 of property listing at 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448Snake River Regional MLS
Stunning New Construction with Space, Style & Scenic Views – Near BYU-Idaho Welcome to this beautifully built 7-bedroom, 3.5-bath home offering the perfect blend of modern comfort and peaceful country living. Located just minutes from Rexburg and BYU-Idaho, yet tucked away in the desirable Old Farm Estates area in Sugar City, this property provides breathing room you've been looking for. Step inside to find a bright, open floor plan featuring gorgeous LVP flooring, a stunning fireplace, and a thoughtfully designed kitchen with quartz countertops, ample cabinetry, and plenty of space for gathering. The spacious laundry room and mudroom, is conveniently located off the garage, add both function and everyday convenience. The basement will be fully finished and includes a separate entrance, a large wet bar, and generous living space—perfect for entertaining, multi-generational living, or future rental potential. With seven bedrooms and three and a half bathrooms, there's room for everyone to spread out comfortably. This brand-new home combines quality craftsmanship, modern finishes, and an unbeatable location close to town while still offering the peace and beauty of small town living. A rare opportunity you won't want to miss. Call agent to find out completion date.

Listing Agent:

License Number:

Offered by: Boss Real Estate

Office Phone: 208-970-9170

MLS: #2181208

Snake River Regional MLS

Date Added: 12/29/2025 08:12:20 pm

Last Update: 03/21/2026 12:23:04 am

Days on Market: 85

Interior

  • General: 2nd Kitchen, Apartment
  • Appliances: Dishwasher, Microwave, Electric Range, Refrigerator
  • Laundry: Main Level, See Remarks
  • Basement: Finished, Full
  • Flooring: Luxury Vinyl, Carpet
  • A/C: true, Central Air
  • Heating: true, Natural Gas, Forced Air

Exterior

  • Style: See Remarks, Other
  • Parking: 2 Stalls, Attached, Parking spaces: 2

Construction

  • Roofing: Architectural
  • General: Frame, Vinyl Siding, One, Concrete Perimeter

Location

  • Originating MLS: Snake River
  • County: Madison

Lot

  • Zoning: OLD FARM ESTATES DIV 4 LOT 13 BLOCK 8 06N40 SEC 9, RPS4OF40080130

Utilities

  • Utilities: Rocky Mountain Power
  • Water: Public
  • Sewer: Public Sewer

Financial

  • Source: Snake River
  • Exclusions: Sellers/Builders Personal Property.

Property

  • Year Built: 2025
  • Type: Single Family Home
  • Style: See Remarks, Other
  • Parcel #: RPS4OF40080130

Schools

  • Elementary: Central 322EL
  • Middle: Sugar Salem 322JH
  • High: Sugar Salem 322HS

powered by

03/20/2026$535,000@ 173 per ft²↓0.92592592592593%
12/29/2025Active
12/29/2025$540,000@ 175 per ft²Listed

Listing Broker

Melissa Ward
1 @
Email: melissa@archibaldbagley.com
Location: AL

Property For Sale

All Listings in Sugar City
Single Family Homes in Sugar City
Condos in Sugar City
Townhouses in Sugar City
Multi-Family in Sugar City
Land in Sugar City

Homes in Sugar City by Price Range

Homes Under $100k in Sugar City
Homes Under $200k in Sugar City
Homes Under $300k in Sugar City
Homes Under $400k in Sugar City
Homes Under $500k in Sugar City
Homes Over $500k in Sugar City

Homes in Sugar City by Bedrooms

1 Bedroom Homes in Sugar City
2 Bedroom Homes in Sugar City
3 Bedroom Homes in Sugar City
4 Bedroom Homes in Sugar City
5 Bedroom Homes in Sugar City
5+ Bedroom Homes in Sugar City

MLS: #2181208

Source: Snake River Regional MLS

<IMG SRC='https://d37ukvrrv3in12.cloudfront.net/mls/logos/idx.png' ALT='IDX'><IMG SRC='https://d37ukvrrv3in12.cloudfront.net/mls/logos/equalhousing.png' ALT='Equal Housing'> All information is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed. Consult with your real estate professional to verify the provided information. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data exchange (“IDX”) program of Snake River MLS®. The IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All information is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed. Consult with your real estate professional to verify the provided information. NOTICE: All real estate advertised herein is subject to the Federal Fair Housing Act, which Acts make it illegal to make or publish any advertisement that indicates any preference, limitation, or discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national origin. Snake River MLS® and this broker will not knowingly accept any advertising for real estate which is in violation of the law. All persons are hereby informed that all dwellings advertised are available on an equal opportunity basis. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright© 2026 Snake River MLS®. All Rights Reserved. Data displayed may be a portion of, and not a complete set of all listings published in the MLS.

View Listing
Home > Listings > ID > Sugar City > 545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448

545 S Cutler Avenue, Sugar City, ID 83448 is a 6 Bed, 4 Bath, 3,085 Sq Ft, 0.13 Acres, Single Family Home built in 2025.

This property is currently available and was listed by Snake River Regional MLS on 12/29/2025 08:12:20 pm. The MLS # for the property is MLS #2181208.

Powered by CT IDX Pro+ & RealtyWatch Solutions.

Copyright © 2026 archibaldbagley.com

Powered by archibaldbagley.com